Think Your Kid Is Gifted? Join The Club!
Posted by Asflutz at 11:00 PM on August 29, 2008
It seems appropriate somehow that two days after my husband grilled me about our district's gifted program – "What grade does it start? You're not sure? Can you call and find out?" – Parenting.com posted an essay about the increasing number of parents that believe their cherished offspring are gifted, when in fact, they're not.
Statistically speaking, it's very unusual to have a child that tests as gifted: only 2-5% of kids meet the requirements. True prodigies – you know, the kids who go to Harvard when they're 9 years old – are much more rare – only 1 or 2 out of a million children qualify.
Despite all those educational toys, videos and classes out there for babies on up, experts agree that none of those will help place your child on the path to gifted-ness. Being gifted is pretty much hard-wired. Pushing too hard will only frustrate you and your kid.
And finally, a note to those mums and dads of kids who really are truly, spectacularly gifted: please don't brag about your wunderkinds under the guise of complaining about the difficulties of parenting a child who's so bored at school, because he's so much smarter than the teacher. You never know – the parent you're moaning to at ballet class or at the neighborhood playground may have a child with learning disabilities, and would gladly swap their problems for yours.
I read the first three paragraphs of this article nodding and smiling. Any length of time reading/posting on parenting forums or chatting at playgroups will expose an incredible desire among some parents to see their child officially (but politically correctly) labelled as ‘better’ than other children.
I disagree with the spirit of the last paragraph however. The well established fact is that any unmet special education need can lead to difficulties like school refusal or behavioural/social problems in classrooms. I think it is a bit uncharitable to assume that anybody expressing a legitimate concern about this is disguising a brag.